ATO issues alert on guarantee arrangements and Division 7A

A new taxpayer alert raises concerns about certain arrangements involving guarantees by private companies for third-party loans.

The ATO this week has issued taxpayer alert TA 2024/2 and taxation determination TD 2024/D3 which explain its views on where section 109U of the ITAA may apply to arrangements where a private company gives a guarantee to another private company.

The ATO issued the taxpayer alert to warn entities and tax practitioners about its concerns regarding contrived arrangements seeking to circumvent Division 7A.

"The arrangements involve a profitable private company guaranteeing a loan made by a bank, or other financial institution, to a related private company with - minimal or no distributable surplus. Amounts are then loaned or paid to a shareholder or associate of a shareholder," the ATO said.

"We consider the arrangements are not effective and that Division 7A would apply to deem the private company which gave the guarantee to have paid an unfranked dividend. Alternatively, Part IVA of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (the general anti-avoidance rule) may apply."

The ATO stated in the taxpayer alert that it is currently reviewing arrangements under which:

A private company (the first company) guarantees a loan made by a financial institution to a related private company that has no or minimal distributable surplus.
The related company on-lends (or pays) some or all of the amount borrowed from the financial institution to the first company's shareholders (or their associates) on terms that do not comply with the requirements of Division 7A of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Division 7A).

The Tax Office said the alert only applies to arrangements that, when viewed objectively, involve a series of steps intended to circumvent the operation of Division 7A.

The ATO said it is concerned that taxpayers may be entering these arrangements on the misunderstanding that section 109U, within Division 7A, only applies if the third-party lender is a private company.

"This is not the case. Section 109U requires the entity which makes the payment or loan to the shareholders to be a private company, but it does not require the entity to which the guarantee is given to also be a private company."

BDO tax partner Mark Molesworth warned the ATO would need to be careful with its approach set out in the alert and determination, as taxpayers may fall into these situations with no intention of avoiding tax.

Molesworth said while the ATO said it will only pursue arrangements that are objectively designed to get around Division 7A, it doesn't provide any detail on what objective facts would mean that the arrangement is considered to be an attempt to circumvent Division 7A.

"We're relying on the Commissioner's approach which is not ideal for certainty for taxpayers."

"It's also been dropped two weeks before Christmas so advisors and their clients are now going to be scrambling around working out who's provided guarantees to banks and who the banks have lent to."

By Miranda Brownlee
13-12-24
accounantsdaily.com.au

Mark Lisle

Mark is our managing partner and has been with the firm for over 36 years. He brings a wealth of experience in all areas of our business, including business advisory, taxation and self managed superannuation.

Mark’s ethos is that good advice stems from working closely with our clients and being prepared to go that extra step to assist them in meeting their goals and optimising their financial position.

Mark is a Fellow of Chartered Accountants Australia and New Zealand, an accredited SMSF Specialist and a registered SMSF auditor.

Outside of work, Mark enjoys trying to keep fit and spending time down at his “second home” in Port Fairy.

Josh Laing

Joshua began working at Rundles in 1999 whilst still completing his Bachelor of Business (Accountancy) degree at RMIT. After graduating in 2001 he was admitted to the Institute of Chartered Accountants Australia and New Zealand in 2004. Joshua spent two years working in London before returning to Rundles in 2006.

Josh has a wealth of knowledge across a broad range of industries as well as in Self Managed Superannuation. Josh enjoys working with family groups and businesses to ensure they’re structured correctly to maximise asset protection, succession planning and management of tax.

Married with 2 children, Josh spends his weekends with his family and following the Tigers.

Brad Roach

Brad has been a part of the Rundles Team since 1996 and became a Partner of the firm in 2014. During his time at Rundles, Brad has developed a strong relationship with his clients across a wide range of industries and is dedicated to assisting them to reach their personal and business goals.

Brad is passionate about seeing his clients succeed and utilises his extensive experience in public practice to provide a holistic service to his clients. He also has a wealth of experience in superannuation, particularly self managed superannuation funds.

In his spare time, Brad likes to play a round of golf with friends and enjoys watching his two sons play various sports.

Peter Davison

Peter graduated from RMIT with a Bachelor of Business (Accountancy) with distinction in 1976. He joined Rundles upon graduating. Peter has been a member of the Institute of Chartered Accountants since 1979 and a Fellow since 1991. As an active yachtie of many years, Peter can often be found on the water. Otherwise, he and his wife spend time with their friends and extended family.

Sandy Gilbert

Sandy was admitted to the Institute of Chartered Accountants in 1973 and has been a Fellow since 1983. He gained extensive experience in auditing and accounting services over seven years at Pannell Kerr Forster before joining Rundles in 1973. Sandy is married with three children. A former amateur footballer of some note, Sandy is still an avid follower of the game and enjoys weekends at his country retreat.