Scotts CA Logo

News

7 Steps to Dealing With a Legal Issue or Dispute

If you run a business for any length of time, you will likely get involved with disagreements and disputes with your associates, whether they be customers, employees, suppliers or competitors.

.

Some legal issues or disputes are more serious than others. Nevertheless, all legal issues and disputes need to be dealt with efficiently and quickly in order to prevent them from escalating. This article will delve into seven ways you can deal with a legal issue or dispute. 

1. Have a Plan 

You never know when a legal issue or dispute may arise during the course of your business, so it is always a good idea to be prepared. The key to ensuring that legal issues and disputes are dealt with efficiently is ensuring that you have an effective dispute resolution system set up.

The result of having such a system in place is that it can spring into action when needed, thus saving you from making hasty decisions when an issue arises. This can be as simple as having a dispute resolution clause in your contracts or the terms and conditions of your services. 

2. Review the Contract 

If your legal issue or dispute relates to a particular contract, you should review the contract in question. The important clauses to look for are:

  • the clause that relates to the particular dispute; 
  • a dispute resolution clause, which sets out the procedures should any dispute arise; and
  • the termination clause, which sets out how the parties to a legal agreement can end their contractual relationship.

Usually, these clauses will outline the steps that must be taken to resolve the dispute before escalating any further. Often they will have a mandatory Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) clause in an attempt to resolve the dispute in the most efficient, timely and cost-friendly manner, without the need for court proceedings. It is important to note that ADR is not always appropriate for certain disputes. For example, if you need an urgent court order or injunction to stop the other party from taking certain action, ADR may be unsuitable.

3. Speak to a Lawyer

You will likely need to speak with a lawyer if you are involved in a legal issue or dispute. This will apply even if it is minor issue.

A lawyer will give advice on your legal position and can guide you in your approach and discuss your options moving forward. This guidance is best sought at the beginning of the dispute when your strategy can still be mapped and changed easily. Ideally, you want to avoid beginning legal action and then consulting a lawyer, only to learn the lawyer advises a different course.

4. Attempt to Reconcile

It is sensible to attempt to reconcile with the other party to your legal issue or dispute if at all possible. Taking a legal issue or dispute into the legal arena is usually very time-consuming and can be expensive. You should carefully consider, along with your legal adviser, whether the severity of the dispute warrants legal action. The first step to resolving the dispute is to communicate with the other side. Put your concerns in writing or arrange a call or meeting to explore possible solutions. 

5. Arbitration 

Arbitration is a form of alternative dispute resolution. In many ways, it is similar to court proceedings but much more flexible and sometimes less costly. Some contracts will include requirements for arbitration in a dispute resolution clause. Generally, the parties to the issue can choose an arbitrator and agree on the procedures and processes to be followed. This ensures you can resolve the dispute in a manner suitable to the party’s needs and the industry standards involved. You can, however, agree to binding arbitration when a dispute arises. Whether arbitration is a good option will depend on the circumstances of your legal issue or dispute. This is why you should work with a lawyer who can advise you on these matters.

6. Mediation

Mediation is a less formal type of ADR that involves parties meeting with an experienced mediator to attempt to resolve the dispute. It has a high success rate and is less structured and, therefore, quicker and cheaper than arbitration or going to court. The mediator does not make a binding determination about the dispute but guides the parties through all options to resolve it. 

7. Litigation

If you cannot resolve your legal issue or dispute through communication, discussion, compromise and possibly ADR, you may need to move to litigation. Obviously, this means getting the courts involved.

Litigation is generally expensive. The court will usually order that the losing party pays the successful party’s costs, but this is only about 60% -80% of the total out-of-pocket costs, depending on the type of cost order made. Litigation is also very time-consuming, with some matters taking several years to resolve in the courts. For all these reasons, we always recommend litigation as a last resort and attempt to resolve matters outside the courts wherever possible.

Key Takeaways

The key to resolving a legal issue dispute as effectively and cheaply as possible is to work with the right legal professional at the right time.

 

 

 

Meryem Aydogan
Law Graduate
legalvision.com.au

May 29, 2024

Hot Issues

David Scott

David Scott

Partner

Chartered Accountant, Bachelor of Business (Accounting), Diploma of Financial Planning

David began his professional career in 1978 before returning to Geelong and establishing his own practice in 1987. Over nearly four decades, the firm has continued to grow and evolve into what is now Scotts Chartered Accountants.

David works closely with business owners and SMSF clients, bringing extensive experience across tax, business and superannuation matters. He has always believed in staying ahead of change, continuing to improve and making sure clients have the information they need to make confident decisions. His long held belief that “knowledge is power” continues to shape the way he works with clients and the wider Scotts team.

David is passionate about building a strong team and helping business owners look beyond the numbers, with a focus on understanding their business, identifying opportunities and planning for the future.

Outside of work, David is an avid runner and adventure traveller. He has completed multiple half and full marathons, including a marathon on all seven continents, along with challenges such as Everest Base Camp, Mount Kilimanjaro, the Kokoda Trail and the Marathon des Sables.

Larry Caravallo

Larry Cavallo

Partner

Chartered Accountant, Bachelor of Accounting and Bachelor of Commerce

Larry is passionate about helping clients grow their businesses through practical advice and strong, long term relationships. He takes the time to understand what clients want to achieve and enjoys working alongside them as their business grows and changes.

Larry believes accounting should be clear and easy to understand, with a focus on giving clients useful information and advice they can act on.

Outside of work, Larry enjoys gardening and playing golf.

Jessica Markewicz

Jessica Markewicz

Partner

Chartered Accountant, Bachelor of Commerce, majoring in Accounting and Financial Planning

Jess has over 20 years of experience working closely with businesses to help them achieve their financial and strategic goals. She works with clients across taxation, business planning, compliance and growth, with a focus on practical advice and building long term relationships based on trust and personalised service.

Jess has a strong interest in property and business development and is passionate about helping clients make informed decisions that support their long term success.

Outside of work, Jess loves travelling and making memories with her family, whether exploring new destinations or enjoying adventures closer to home.

Chris Scott

Chris Scott

Partner

Chartered Accountant, Bachelor of Commerce, majoring in Accounting and Management

Chris works predominantly with business clients, helping them navigate challenges, identify opportunities and work towards their long term goals. He enjoys working with a diverse range of businesses and developing practical solutions that reflect each client’s individual circumstances.

Outside of work, Chris is the Treasurer and an active player at Thomson Football & Netball Club, where he is passionate about supporting community sport. He also enjoys spending time with his wife Lauren, their two children, Jasper and Juke, and their dog, Leo.

Thomas Scott

Thomas Scott

Senior Client Manager

Chartered Accountant, Bachelor of Commerce, majoring in Accounting and Management

Tom works closely with business owners and family groups to help them understand their position and make confident decisions.

His approach is practical and personal. He focuses on making the numbers clear, explaining what matters and helping clients plan ahead, rather than just looking at things after the fact.

What drives Tom is helping clients build a business that supports the life they want and being someone they can rely on along the way.

Outside of work, Tom enjoys spending time with family and friends, watching sport and being a long suffering North Melbourne supporter.

Connor Jervies

Connor Jervies

Senior Client Manager

Chartered Accountant, Bachelor of Commerce, majoring in Accounting and Finance

Connor works closely with business owners across accounting, tax and business advisory. He enjoys helping clients understand their numbers, improve profitability and build stronger businesses through clear and practical advice.

Connor has a particular interest in working with growing businesses and helping clients plan ahead and make decisions that support their long term success.

Outside of work, Connor is passionate about local football and enjoys playing, coaching and contributing to his community club.

Hamish Irvin

Hamish Irvin

Accountant

Commerce graduate, majoring in Accounting, currently completing his final year of Chartered Accountant studies

Hamish has been part of the Scotts team for three years and works closely with the senior client managers, particularly Tom, across a range of client work. He enjoys building relationships with clients and is focused on continuing to develop his experience while growing his own client base.

Outside of work, Hamish is the ultimate sports tragic and will watch or play just about anything. He also umpires football on weekends, which keeps him active and involved in the game despite, in his words, having little footballing ability.

Hugh Menzies

Hugh Menzies

Accountant

Bachelor of Commerce, majoring in Financial Planning and Accounting

Hugh works with small business clients across a range of accounting and tax matters, including individual and business tax returns, financial statements and Business Activity Statements. He enjoys working with clients to help them understand their position and support them as they build their businesses and work towards their goals.

Outside of work, Hugh is a keen sports fan and enjoys spending time with family and friends.

Hugh Menzies

Iggy Roberts

Accountant

Bachelor of Business Accounting

Iggy works across a range of accounting and tax work, with a focus on preparing financial statements and supporting clients with their tax compliance obligations. He enjoys working as part of the wider Scotts team and helping ensure client work is completed accurately and efficiently.

Outside of work, Iggy enjoys staying active, catching up with mates and keeping up with the footy.

Hugh Menzies

Liam Purtill

Junior Accountant

Currently studying a Bachelor of Commerce at Deakin University

Liam works across a range of accounting and tax work, including preparing financial statements, Business Activity Statements and tax returns for businesses and individuals. He is passionate about continuing to grow within the firm, developing his experience and contributing to the wider team to support clients and their goals.

Outside of work, Liam enjoys playing golf, catching up with mates and playing football for Thomson Football Club.

Cooper Lynch

Cooper Lynch

Junior Accountant

Currently studying a Bachelor of Business at Deakin University

Cooper works across a range of accounting and tax work while continuing to build his experience as part of the Scotts team. He enjoys developing his skills, learning about different businesses and contributing to the wider team to support clients.

Outside of work, Cooper enjoys spending time with friends, following football and basketball and travelling. He also plays football for Thomson Football Club.

Cooper Lynch

Ziggy Lee

Junior Accountant

Currently studying a Bachelor of Commerce, majoring in Accounting

Ziggy works across a range of accounting and tax work, including tax returns, financial statements and Business Activity Statements, while continuing to build his experience as part of the Scotts team. He enjoys learning about different businesses, developing his technical skills and working alongside the wider team to support clients.

Outside of work, Ziggy plays football for Leopold and is a passionate Essendon supporter.

Ruby Saunders

Ruby Saunders

Administration Assistant

Ruby joined Scotts in February 2024 after moving to Geelong from Northeast Victoria, where she previously worked for a local accounting firm as a receptionist.

She provides administrative support across the wider team, including greeting clients, managing incoming phone calls and emails and scheduling appointments. Ruby always aims to be as efficient as possible so clients and staff can get what they need, when they need it.

What Ruby enjoys most about working at Scotts is that every day is different and being part of a close knit team that supports each other.

Outside of work, Ruby enjoys spending time with family and friends and going to the beach.

Ruby Saunders

Ella Cooper

Administration Assistant

Ella supports the wider Scotts team across a range of administrative tasks and enjoys building positive relationships with clients over the phone and by email.

Her role includes collating tax packages, data entry, managing bookings and helping direct client queries to the right person within the team.

Outside of work, Ella enjoys arts and crafts, photography and taking time to relax.

Claire Markewicz

Claire Surace

Administration Assistant

Claire supports the team across a broad range of administrative functions, including accounts payable and receivable, ASIC compliance and the administration of the firm’s trust account.

She is responsible for helping ensure financial transactions are processed accurately, regulatory obligations are met and trust account records are properly maintained.

Outside of work, Claire is usually kept busy running around after her son, Lenny. She also enjoys reading, cooking and relaxing in her spare time.

Mercedes Perez

Mercedes Perez

Receptionist

Certificate IV in Office Administration

Mercedes joined Scotts in November 2022 and is often one of the first points of contact for clients visiting or calling the office. She supports the wider team across reception and administration, including managing phone calls, appointments, client queries and the day to day running of the front office.

Mercedes is energetic, friendly and enjoys building strong relationships with clients and supporting the team wherever she can. She values being part of a close knit team and contributing to a positive experience for everyone who comes through the office.

She also makes a great coffee.