Clear Picture Logo

Latest News

ATO’s hands tied with scrapping on-hold debts, expert says

The Tax Office lacks power under current laws to do anything about the wildly unpopular scheme despite plans to review its approach, according to a UNSW professor.

.

Relief for taxpayers with on-hold debts resurrected by the ATO is impossible to achieve without government intervention due to the Commissioner’s inflexible powers, according to one expert.

The ATO announced on Thursday it paused activities around re-raising liabilities previously deemed “uneconomical to pursue” after backlash from the community over the program’s fairness and transparency. 

But UNSW associate professor Ann Kayis-Kumar said individuals with on-hold debts hoping for a blank slate would be disappointed because “the ATO’s hands are tied” with no power to write the amounts off.

“The ATO’s in a tricky position. Being responsible for collections and compliance, it needs to walk that delicate balance between collection but also not disproportionately affecting the most disadvantaged in our community,” she said.

 

“But that raises the question of the discretion available to the ATO.”

Only the finance minister had the power to permanently write off debts owed to the government, she said.

While the ATO could release certain taxpayers’ debts under “serious hardship” provisions contained in the Income Tax Assessment Act, in practice they were ineffective due to being “so outdated and drafted in such a counterintuitive way”.

For example, the current provisions meant the ATO would be less likely to grant hardship relief to taxpayers with more debt.

“That just does not square with reality,” she said. “We need a legislative fix and it really can't be overstated how important that is.”

In the ATO’s statement released yesterday, it announced it would pause the on-hold debts program due to the “frustration” and “concern” caused to the community.

“The ATO has paused all action in relation to debts placed on hold prior to 2017 whilst we review and develop a pragmatic and sensible way forward that takes into account concerns raised by the community,” it said.

However, it said it had “no discretion under the law to waive these amounts and must use any future refund to reduce these debts”.

“In the past, the ATO has excluded some debts from being recovered from taxpayer refunds in this way through long-standing exclusionary criteria, such as for taxpayers on low incomes. However, the Australian Government Solicitor advised this was not in line with the law and so the ATO cannot continue this practice,” it said.

The announcement follows an earlier apology issued by the ATO in November for the “unnecessary distress” caused by its “public awareness campaign” that first alerted taxpayers to the debts a month earlier.

The campaign involved the sending of 200,000 letters to taxpayers and tax agents listing the sums without containing further details of their origins.

Internal documents obtained by The Guardian this week revealed the on-hold debts were the result of the ATO’s gradual removal of filters in its automated systems.

The planned removal of the final filter – debts placed on hold prior to 2017 – would have expanded the program to apply to $15 billion from 1.8 million entities, the documents said.

Ms Kayis-Kumar, who runs UNSW’s pro-bono Tax & Business Advisory Clinic, said on-hold debts disproportionately impacted financially vulnerable individuals without access to tax advice.

Tax agents also reported confusion and increased workloads in attempting to reconcile the debts.

But the community’s concerns could be addressed by giving the Commissioner a “general public policy ground of relief”, in addition to reworking the serious hardship provisions, she said.

A general discretion, as seen in other countries like the US, could allow the flexibility needed to scrap the on-hold debt program in line with public consensus.

“If we adopted something inspired by the public policy ground of relief in the US, the ATO would be able to exercise that discretion in situations like what we’re seeing here,” she said.

“You want decision-makers to be able to make decisions that are in line with community expectations.”

“If we want to see a wholescale improvement to the status quo, we need more reform.”

 

 

 

 

 

Christine Chen
23 February 2024
accountantsdaily.com.au

Hot Issues

Craig Byron

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Fusce efficitur ligula id justo blandit, sit amet accumsan magna scelerisque. Phasellus tincidunt ipsum nec semper sagittis. Suspendisse suscipit, orci sed gravida dapibus, elit est porta ligula, vel convallis metus urna et ante. Pellentesque aliquam erat sodales sem blandit, ac facilisis magna mattis. Aliquam id lorem eu mauris bibendum facilisis in sit amet leo.

Morbi non ante vitae velit vehicula vehicula vitae euismod ex. Ut pretium rhoncus lacus in tincidunt. Suspendisse vulputate, diam eget viverra feugiat, magna velit scelerisque velit, vel posuere eros sem ut felis. Sed pellentesque justo in eros iaculis, et consequat nibh sollicitudin. Ut facilisis sit amet turpis sed cursus. Sed tincidunt neque arcu, a rutrum lectus elementum quis.

Vivamus nisi lectus, malesuada vel maximus a, lobortis in justo. Donec turpis diam, consectetur eu justo ut, accumsan malesuada nisl.

Service 1

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Mauris eget pulvinar velit. Pellentesque condimentum felis enim, vitae mollis felis feugiat sed. Fusce quis eros rutrum, blandit sem ut, pharetra felis. Aenean pulvinar et risus et rhoncus. Maecenas feugiat consectetur risus, eu lobortis erat viverra vitae. Nam tempor tellus bibendum, tempus elit a, laoreet metus.

Sed consectetur quam quis purus lobortis, sed rhoncus enim finibus. Sed fringilla eu lectus sit amet pretium. Ut tempus aliquam iaculis. Nulla enim elit, pellentesque ut maximus a, efficitur eu risus. Praesent finibus interdum finibus. Pellentesque et maximus dui. Maecenas consequat suscipit eleifend. Curabitur placerat quam nulla, et fringilla nisl consectetur eu. Proin posuere, nisl in viverra egestas, leo urna consequat risus, at euismod orci est quis sem. Praesent convallis viverra elit eu lacinia.

  • Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit.
  • Nulla commodo ex eu blandit maximus.
  • Cras vulputate libero vel felis mattis, a ultricies arcu pellentesque.
  • Etiam suscipit turpis a mauris fermentum, quis accumsan est dapibus.
Contact Us

Tax Diary

General Calculators

 

Accounting Videos

Secure File Transfer

Secure File Transfer is a facility that allows the safe and secure exchange of confidential files or documents between you and us.

Email is very convenient in our business world, there is no doubting that. However email messages and attachments can be intercepted by third parties, putting your privacy and identity at risk if used to send confidential files or documents. Secure File Transfer eliminates this risk.

Login to Secure File Transfer, or contact us if you require a username and password.